Agenda and minutes

Venue: By Zoom. View directions

Contact: Wyn Richards, Scrutiny Manager and Head of Democratic Services 

Media

Items
No. Item

1.

Apologies

To receive apologies for absence.

Minutes:

An apology for absence was received from County Councillor T Van-Rees.

 

The Committee was advised of the resignation of Mr G Robson as a Co-Opted Member on the Committee, and that a replacement appointment would need to be made. The Chair thanked Mr Robson for his contribution at meetings of the Committee.

2.

Disclosures of interest

To receive any disclosures of interest by Members relating to items to be considered at the meeting.

Minutes:

Members were advised that they all had a personal interest in any matter relating to school budgets where they had been appointed as an LEA Governor. However, this was not in addition a Prejudicial Interest in accordance with the Members' Code of Conduct.

 

For non LEA appointed governors it would also be a Personal Interest, but not a Prejudicial Interest in accordance with a dispensation granted by the Standards Committee in June 2021.

 

3.

Declarations of Party Whip

To receive disclosures of prohibited party whips which a Member has been given in relation to the meeting in accordance with Section 78(3) of the Local Government Measure 2011.

 

(NB: Members are reminded that under Section 78 Members having been given a prohibited party whip cannot vote on a matter before the Committee.)

Minutes:

The Committee did not receive any disclosures of prohibited party whips which a Member has been given in relation to the meeting in accordance with Section 78(3) of the Local Government Measure 2011.

4.

School Outturn Positions 31 March 2021 and Budget Plans 2021-22 pdf icon PDF 1 MB

To receive and consider the report of the Portfolio Holder for Education and the Portfolio Holder for Finance.

Minutes:

Documents Considered:

·                 Joint Report of the Portfolio Holders for Education and Finance – School Outturn Positions 31 March 2021 and Budget Plans 2021-22.

 

Issues Discussed:

·                 £80.8m delegated to schools by the Council for 2021-22. In relation to deficits, warning notices issues to those schools with deficits of greatest concern in July 2019. Since then, schools have been working to improve their budget positions.

·                 At 1st April 2020, ten warning notices in place, two were during the year and two new notices issued. In one case the school refused to meet the conditions of the warning notice and had their financial delegation withdrawn.

·                 By 1st April 2021 there were nine warning notices in place and one school having financial delegation withdrawn. By 31st March 2021 the total cumulative reserves for schools was in a surplus position of £2.9m. The total for schools carry forward balances was a surplus of £3.2m. This is an improved position where previously it was projected to be in deficit i.e. an improvement of £5.5m during the year. This is partly due to the additional £3.3m grant funding, and an improvement in in-year positions of schools who were projecting deficits, partly due to schools being closed for a time and due to improvement in budgets by the schools themselves.

·                 At 31st March 2021 there are eighty one schools in a surplus position with a combined cumulative surplus of £6.9m. There are fourteen schools in a deficit balance position with a combined cumulative deficit of £3.7m.

·                 Cumulative balances remain a concern and a significant risk to the authority but schools are working with the Council to bring in-year budgets into balance and halt the growth of cumulative deficits.

 

·                 Questions:

 

Is this the same report considered by Cabinet or what are the changes.

This is the same report

Section 3.4 - What would the position have been if this was an usual school year (without the surplus and Welsh Government intervention). How are we in a position of surplus and how reliable is this as an indicator for the future

Many variables have come together at the same time. Welsh Government provided significant funding to offset costs incurred last year and provided grant funding for the current year. Schools were not expected to spend this additional funding quickly, as it was to improve the opportunity of experiences for learners so the funding is held in surpluses. Schools were assured that these surpluses would not be clawed back by the authority.

There were also other factors such as schools being closed for three months so many of the overheads were not incurred. At the end of the year they were open with ventilation required so doors and windows may have been open which led to higher energy costs.

There have been efforts by schools to deal with their budgets. These are the outturns in the first financial year since the Estyn inspection. A change in the funding formula assisted as well, especially in the secondary sector.  ...  view the full minutes text for item 4.

5.

Update on Strategic Equality Objective 5 - Improve Opportunities and Outcomes for Children Living in Poverty pdf icon PDF 485 KB

To receive and consider the report of the Interim Chief Education Officer.

Minutes:

Documents Considered:

·                 Report of the Interim Chief Education Officer – Update on Strategic Equality Objective 5.

 

Issues Discussed:

·                 The Education Service is the lead Service Area for this equality objective across the Council, working with other service areas.

·                 The work aims to improve the opportunities and outcomes for children living in poverty and links to actions contained within the Children's Commissioner's report "A Charter for Change: Protecting Welsh Children from the Impact of Poverty".

·                 The first part of the report focussed on the actions for 2020-21, including:

·                 Pupil Development Grant;

·                 School Holiday Enrichment Programme (SHEP);

·                 Welsh Government's Period Dignity programme;

·                 Statutory Guidance on School Uniform;

·                 Free School Meals Entitlement and Parent Pay;

·                 Clothing Grants;

·                 Supporting families who are "in work" poverty;

·                 Reducing Council Tax for foster carers and Care Leavers;

·                 Financial Hardship support;

·                 Housing Support through a Discretionary Housing Payment Scheme;

·                 Play Resource Packs.

·                 The second part of the report focussed on the progress on A Charter for Change Report, including;

·                 Meeting Basic Needs;

·                 The School Experience;

·                 Inclusion and Opportunity in the Community;

·                 Welsh Government and Local Authorities;

·                 Work with Credit Unions to widen the network of School Savings schemes.

 

·                 Questions:

 

There is really good work being undertaken which is encouraging to read. Free School Meals and Period dignity are significant issues, as is work around the summer activity programme.

Under the uniform section it provides an example out of county. Next year the uniform exchange operating from the Hive in Llandrindod could be mentioned.

With regard to the link to credit unions and savings, could this be promoted more and help young people with safe financing.

There needs to be meaningful engagement with young people and schools about the transformation process so that this detail can be included in next year's report.

 

Councillor Jake Berriman declared an interest as a possible member of the Red Kite Credit Union.

 

The Chair suggested that it would be worth considering linking locations for the distribution of school uniforms with food banks across the county, so that there is one point of contact rather than a link to each individual school.

With regard to the Credit union this was a specific recommendation from the Children's Commissioner which was included in the action plan. Engagement work with schools and learners will commence in September to see what's practical to put in place.

Page 20 - The Pupil Deprivation Grant Access grant support is for years 1, 5, 8,9 and 11. What about pupils in years 2,3,4,6,7 and 10.

 

Page 22 - mention of school uniform and the use of council run buildings and resources - what is this system and how does it work.

 

Page 24 - mention of checks on awards for council tax reduction for families with children on FSM (Free School Meals) of school age who do not claim FSM but families have eligible income. The Income and Awards Team then award and write to advise families they have done so. Is this the wrong way around, i.e. should  ...  view the full minutes text for item 5.

6.

Work Programme

To note that future meetings will be held as follows:

 

09-21 TBC

 

15-09-21

 

14.00 - 16.00

Zoom

Mount Street / Cradoc (Cabinet 21-09-21)

Llanbedr (Cabinet 21-09-21)

Churchstoke (Cabinet 21-09-21)

 

08-12-21

 

14.00 - 16.00

Zoom

 

12-01-22

14.00 - 16.00

Zoom

WESP - post consultation (Cabinet 18-01-22)

 

Minutes:

The Committee noted that future meetings were scheduled as follows:

 

09-21 TBC

 

15-09-21

 

14.00 - 16.00

Zoom

 Mount Street / Cradoc (Cabinet 21-09-21)

Llanbedr (Cabinet 21-09-21)

Churchstoke (Cabinet 21-09-21)

08-12-21

 

14.00 - 16.00

Zoom

 

12-01-22

14.00 – 16.00

Zoom

WESP – post consultation (Cabinet 18-01-22)